Brother, Bottle and Blame – what this story teaches, the signs and what to do
From the book – Chapter 17: Helping a Family Member
Brother, Bottle and Blame
Imran, 35, in Kolkata, drinks every evening and more on weekends. He has missed work, lost his temper with his wife and borrowed money. His younger brother Salim is exhausted by lies and promises. He has poured out bottles, shouted and given ultimatums, but the pattern repeats.
Salim speaks to a counsellor who explains that substance use is a health problem, not just poor character, and that shouting often pushes people to hide. She suggests choosing a calm moment, when Imran is sober, and describing specific worries without blame.
What this story explains
Substance use affects the whole family. Supportive, calm conversation and medical help work better than blame, and caregivers need support too.
How to recognise it
-
Drinking daily, with shaking or sweating if he misses it.
-
Missed work, money problems, broken promises.
-
Anger, secrecy and denial.
-
Family exhausted and arguing.
-
Repeated failed attempts to stop alone.
What to do
-
Pick a calm, sober moment.
-
Describe specific behaviours and worries without blame.
-
Offer to go with him to a doctor.
-
Remember that stopping heavy drinking suddenly can be risky, so it needs medical supervision.
-
Avoid covering up or giving money for drink.
-
Look after your own wellbeing too.
Do and don’t
| Do | Don’t |
|---|---|
| Choose a calm moment. | Do not shout or shame. |
| Speak with care. | Do not threaten without following through. |
| Set clear limits. | Do not cover up for him. |
| Seek medical advice. | Do not push sudden withdrawal without a doctor. |
| Look after yourself. | Do not neglect your own health. |
Read the full chapter – Chapter 17: Helping a Family Member
Stories from real life
- The Door That Stayed Closed – Fatima, 15, in Lucknow, has started spending evenings in her room with the door shut. She skips meals, her marks have fallen and she snaps at…
- Appa in the Village – Mr Gowda, 76, lives in a village near Mysuru with his son's family. For months he has been quiet, forgets where he put things, and says,…
- The Daughter Who Held Everything Together – Lakshmi, 40, in Hyderabad, looks after her mother who has schizophrenia, her two children, and works part-time. She gives medicines on time, goes to every appointment,…
- Five Steps for Anil – Anil, 29, in Delhi, has been unusually quiet, has missed work and says little at family dinners. His older sister Rekha feels something is wrong. Remembering…
Shloks
- Tukaram Gatha; cite by first line – The person who treats the broken and suffering as their own family is a true saint. That is where God lives.
More on this topic: Helping a loved one with mental illness – family and relationships
More questions
- The Daughter Who Held Everything Together – what this story teaches, the signs and what to do
- Five Steps for Anil – what this story teaches, the signs and what to do
- What can we learn from the story “Suresh And Meena”?
- Why family support matters?
- Understanding understanding the person's experience – helping a family member
- How to talk?
- Helpful phrases – how to talk
- Unhelpful phrases to avoid – how to talk
- Listening – how to talk
- Understanding encouraging professional help – helping a family member
- How to help a family member who is struggling
- How to set healthy boundaries in relationships